Penn Law Journal Spring 2024

The Journal: University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School
Spring
2024
Spring 2024
SOPHIA Z. LEE
New Dean’s Mission:
Bridging Tradition and Innovation

The Journal

The Journal

Design
Landesberg Design

Senior Contributing Writer
Lindsay Podraza

Contributing Writers and editors
Michelle Kaminsky
Eleanor Mallett
Jay Nachman

Photography
Dave Barbaree
Charles Shan Cerrone

Website
journal.law.upenn.edu

Corrections
Every effort has been made to ensure accuracy. We offer our sincere apologies for any typographical errors or omissions. Please forward any corrections to the attention of:

Contact
University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School
3501 Sansom Street
Philadelphia, PA 19104
alumnijournal@law.upenn.edu

Congratulations to Larry Teitelbaum on his well-deserved retirement, which began at the beginning of January 2024. Larry has been an integral part of the Penn Carey Law community for over two decades. Before joining us in 2003, Larry had a successful career as a journalist, speechwriter, and congressional press secretary, bringing a wealth of experience to our institution. A native of Philadelphia, Larry is known for his passionate support of the Phillies, Eagles, and Sixers, reflecting his love for his hometown and its sense of community. Penn Carey Law wishes him all the best in this new chapter and thanks him for his contributions to the Journal.

On Docket-
Volume. 59, No. 1 Spring 2024

On Docket
Docket
Vol.  59, No. 1, spring 2024
On
Olwethuthando Banele Ndlovu headshot
Olwethuthando Banele Ndlovu LLM’24
Veda Bhadharla headshot
Veda Bhadharla L’24
Kia Del Solar headshot
Kia Del Solar L’25
Darius Iraj headshot
Darius Iraj L’24
Photos: Charles Shan Cerrone
22
Dean Sophia Z. Lee believes in the power of dialogue as she moves Penn Carey Law toward the next decade with respect for the past and excitement about the future.
28
Meet six student leaders who exemplify Penn Carey Law’s dedication to a rich and vibrant culture.
Letters

From The Dean

Photo: Sameer Khan / Fotobuddy
Sophia Z. Lee speaking at podium
ast April, I received the honor of a lifetime when I was named Dean of the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School. I am profoundly grateful and enormously excited for the opportunity to lead one of the top law schools in the country.

As a member of the faculty over the past 14 years, I’ve become intimately acquainted with our esteemed institution. My commitment to Penn Carey Law’s success runs deep and I look forward to shaping the Law School during a new era that is ripe with possibility.

This inaugural column explores what truly sets this Law School apart—our people and vibrant community. Often described as the collegial law school, our modest size fosters close bonds among faculty, students, and staff, creating a dynamic environment in which respect drives creativity and innovation. This interconnected community is a hallmark of Penn Carey Law, shaping an intellectually stimulating atmosphere dedicated to legal excellence.

L dropcap

#PennCareyLaw

illustration of a crowd of blue fish
Students in @RangitadeSilva’s class on women, law, and leadership have produced “Putting Women Back in the Game,” a report exploring issues affecting women’s equality in sports.
tinyurl.com/2vnpjeh9
Blue line
close up of hand wearing blue glove holding vile
Blue line
Prof. Kate Shaw (@KateShaw1) discusses how the SCOTUS decision on a herring fishing case could impact federal agencies’ power at NPR.
tinyurl.com/4sjj6dz7
girls sports team
Blue line
As featured in an NBC News exclusive, a new @QuattroneCenter for the Fair Administration of Justice report finds error-prone field drug tests lead to the wrongful arrest of more than 30,000 Americans each year.
tinyurl.com/3cwtx7n5
In an amicus brief, Prof. Kermit Roosevelt (@kroosevelt93) argues that the U.S. Supreme Court should affirm the Colorado Supreme Court’s decision that keeps Trump off the state’s presidential ballot.
tinyurl.com/yhdsrnbs
Blue line
“Weighing the consequences of disqualification is not the role of a court, especially where, as here, the Constitution explicitly remits that issue to the political process.”
Kermit Roosevelt

#penncareyLaw

illustration of a crowd of blue fish
Prof. Kate Shaw (@KateShaw1) discusses how the SCOTUS decision on a herring fishing case could impact federal agencies’ power at NPR.
tinyurl.com/4sjj6dz7
close up of hand wearing blue glove holding vile
As featured in an NBC News exclusive, a new @QuattroneCenter for the Fair Administration of Justice report finds error-prone field drug tests lead to the wrongful arrest of more than 30,000 Americans each year.
tinyurl.com/3cwtx7n5
girls sports team
Students in @RangitadeSilva’s class on women, law, and leadership have produced “Putting Women Back in the Game,” a report exploring issues affecting women’s equality in sports.
tinyurl.com/2vnpjeh9
“Weighing the consequences of disqualification is not the role of a court, especially where, as here, the Constitution explicitly remits that issue to the political process.”
Kermit Roosevelt
In an amicus brief, Prof. Kermit Roosevelt (@kroosevelt93) argues that the U.S. Supreme Court should affirm the Colorado Supreme Court’s decision that keeps Trump off the state’s presidential ballot.
tinyurl.com/yhdsrnbs

Follow @PennLaw on Twitter for more

News & Events
IN SESSION
Victoria Joseph smiling with her arms crossed

In Pursuit of Justice: Victoria Joseph C’11 L’17 and her role as an attorney in the George Floyd case

From the time Victoria A. Joseph C’11, L’17 began to consider law school, she knew she wanted to help people fight for more equity and justice in their everyday lives, but she never predicted that she would end up working on one of the most pivotal cases in contemporary American history.

In late May 2020, while simultaneously working as an Associate at Hogan Lovells and providing care for her mother, who was terminally ill, Joseph was asked to work on one of the biggest pro bono matters the firm — and this generation — had ever taken on. The prosecution of the former police officers involved in the murder of George Floyd would not only forever impact Joseph’s life, but it would also change the fabric of social and racial justice in America.

“I did not see this coming,” Joseph said. “Being on what I think is the case of the century … was wild. At the time, my mom was at her sickest. And she always mustered up the energy to tell me how proud she was of me. That really kept me going even after her passing.”

News & Events

Citation

Citation
The UN Sustainable Development Goals: A Commentary

The UN Sustainable Development Goals: A Commentary

Rangita de Silva de Alwis, Senior Adjunct Professor of Global Leadership, contributed a chapter
Oxford University Press
T

he commentary serves as an expert compendium on the historic UN sustainable development goals, providing the most up-to-date information on normative and legal questions arising from the incorporation of the SDGs into the international economic, social, and environmental legal frameworks, and on their implementation status.

Rangita de Silva de Alwis, an expert member of the UN Convention on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women, wrote a chapter on gender equality examining whether legal frameworks are in place to promote, enforce, and monitor equality and non-discrimination on the basis of sex. She argues that despite the pandemic, continuing conflict, and rising populism in many parts of the world, states have acknowledged the role of women in economic life by removing some of the legal barriers that impede women’s access to justice.

Each chapter analyzes one of the goals and includes a methodical analysis of the preparatory proceedings that shaped each goal in its present form, an exhaustive examination of their content, and a critical assessment from an international law perspective.

The book is considered a must-read for scholars, practitioners, and those interested in the fields of law, politics, development, economics, environmental studies, and global governance.

Advanced Introduction to Substantive Criminal Law

Advanced Introduction to Substantive Criminal Law

Stephen J. Morse, Ferdinand Wakeman Hubbell Professor of Law and Professor of Psychology & Law in Psychiatry
Edward Elgar Publishing
T

his Advanced Introduction to Substantive Criminal Law explores the doctrines, issues, and controversies in the substantive field of criminal law. Chapters cover important theoretical and doctrinal topics, including the justifications for state blame and punishment, the foundations for criminalization, the prima facie case, affirmative defenses of justification and excuse, and sentencing. Morse uses copious concrete examples drawn from cases, statutes, and extended case studies, including the intricate grading of homicide, to enliven the discussion. In so doing, the author illuminates the challenges and responsibilities surrounding legal concepts of the person.

The book is an ideal read for lawyers and law students interested in criminal law and justice. It is also a valuable resource for law enforcement personnel and anyone looking to understand the role of criminal law as a means to achieve justice and social safety.

black line

News & Events

Service banner in orange

The Life’s Work of John Parvensky L’79: Helping the Homeless

I

n 2015 in Denver, Colorado, former President Bill Clinton toured a new health center site that would serve the homeless. Use of the New Markets Tax Credit made the facility a reality, and Clinton, who crafted the tax credit program in his final year in office, wanted to see his work in action.

“I pointed out a window to the parking lot across the alley and basically told him that once we got this one done, the next project was to build a recuperative center to meet the needs of people being inappropriately discharged from hospitals,” said John Parvensky L’79, who was then the CEO of the Colorado Coalition for the Homeless. “His words were, ‘I bet you will.’”

Clinton’s words proved prophetic. On the cusp of his spring 2023 retirement, Parvensky oversaw the crowning achievement of his 38-year career at the Coalition: the Renaissance Legacy Lofts and Stout Street Recuperative Care Center opened in October 2022.

News & Events
outdoor view of a government building

Three Penn Carey Law Alumni Serve in High-Level Leadership Roles in Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro’s Administration.

Governor Josh Shapiro, the 48th governor of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, tapped three University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School alumni to serve in his administration.

Mira Baylson L’08: Executive Deputy Secretary

Mira Baylson L’08 is the Executive Deputy Secretary of the Commonwealth.

Prior to joining the Department of State, Baylson was an attorney at Cozen O’Connor, focusing her practice on state attorney general investigations and litigation and white-collar defense. Throughout her career, Baylson has dedicated ample time and effort to pro bono efforts, and before entering the private sector, she spent four years as a Public Defender in Philadelphia.

white line

News & Events

Exhibit

Photo: Dave Barbaree

The Gift of Art

Following his service as the Chief Counsel of the Federal Aviation Administration during the Obama-Biden Administration, Reggie Govan L’78 was a Senior Lecturer in Legal Practice Skills during the 2019–2020 academic year. To honor the forty-one 1Ls comprising the class, whose grace and thirst for learning provided a firm foundation for a rewarding and successful teaching experience, Govan donated the notable artwork, Forward Together, to the Law School.

Forward Together depicts Harriet Tubman leading enslaved African Americans to freedom via the Underground Railroad. The artist, Jacob Lawrence, is a master of twentieth-century American Realism. His artwork chronicles the profound influences of African Americans on the cultural, social, and intellectual life and history of America. That painting now adorns a wall on the second floor of Silverman Hall.

The students in Govan’s class were: Eleanor Allen, Ryan Baldwin, Corinne Belkoff, Rebecca Bierstein, Matthew Bunner, Canclong Cai, Amani M. Carter, Grace Haeun Cho, Alexandra Delaney, Bryan Dinner, Jordan Einstein, Evan Elam, Madeline Feldman Fenton, Abraham Flegman, George Frank, Susannah Gagnon, Gwyneth Harrick, Nicolas Harris, Jacob Hirshman, Catherine Kearney, Joseph Kim, Cole Kinie, Matthew Kut, Mackenzie Libbey, William Lyoo, Julia Malave, Zachary Malter, Sum-Mai Nguyen, Caroline Nowlin, Garcia Luis Pacheco, Oliver Paprin, Ravid Reif, Seth Rosenberg, Elle Rothermich, Seth Rubenstein, Carolyn Sharzer, Lucas Slevin, Sarah Stern, Aubrey Thompson, Daniel Turner, and Angela Wu.

News & Events
low angle headshot of Dorothy E. Roberts smiling while wearing cat-eye framed glasses, a red blouse and a black leather jacket

Photo: Sameer Khan / Fotobuddy

Highly Selective American Philosophical Society Elects Dorothy Roberts

Members of the prestigious American Philosophical Society (APS) voted to elect Dorothy E. Roberts, George A. Weiss University Professor of Law and Sociology and the Raymond Pace and Sadie Tanner Mossell Alexander Professor of Civil Rights, as a new member. Founded in 1743 by Benjamin Franklin for the purpose of “promoting useful knowledge,” the APS is the oldest learned society in the United States.

With fewer than 30 new members elected annually, the APS honors and engages distinguished scientists, civic and cultural leaders, and preeminent scholars across a range of academic disciplines.

“I’m very honored by the American Philosophical Society’s recognition of my scholarship, which I hope provides useful knowledge for building a more just and humane world,” said Roberts. “Penn has been a wonderful academic home, and it’s especially gratifying to join my distinguished Penn Carey Law colleague Anita Allen as an APS member.”

News & Events

Judge Beetlestone Breaks Gender and Color Barrier As New Chancellor at the University of Liverpool

In an unprecedented move since its charter 120 years ago, the University of Liverpool broke with tradition and appointed the Honorable Wendy Beetlestone L’93 as Chancellor. Since the University’s founding, there have been ten other Chancellors: aristocrats, politicians, academics, captains of industry, and (most recently) a famed writer. Judge Beetlestone is the University’s first woman and first person of color to take the title. Judge Beetlestone, an alumna, who earned a degree in philosophy from the University of Liverpool, was installed in July 2023, accepting the role with pleasure and gratitude.

Unlike American universities, the chancellorships at British schools are largely ceremonial. As Chancellor, Judge Beetlestone, who has been a judge for the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania since 2015, presides over the University’s two annual graduation ceremonies.

“At each graduation ceremony over which I preside, I give (what I hope is) an inspirational speech, and as the students walk across the stage, doff my cap to each one of them.” Between ceremonies this summer, she gained an in-depth understanding of the University by talking with members of the academic faculty, as well as administrative and student leaders. “I’m spending time with the best and the brightest at an institution I love, which is unbelievably gratifying,” she said.

white line

News & Events

Discovery

Photo Courtesy: U.S. Space Force

The U.S. Space Force Affects Day-to-Day Life More Than We Know

W

hen he was named General Counsel of the United States Air Force in 2018, General Thomas Ayres L’91 embarked on the momentous task of creating a new subset of the American military, which had not been done since the establishment of the Air Force in 1947.

Working closely with then-Vice President Mike Pence, members of Congress, and congressional staff and space professionals across the Secretary of Defense offices, he made the United States Space Force a reality.

General Ayres, who retired as an Army Major General after 33 years, joined Voyager Space in June 2021 as Chief Legal Officer and Counsel. His active military career included the role of Deputy leader of the Army’s Judge Advocate General’s Corps in addition to several combat tours in Iraq and Afghanistan. He said navigating the bureaucracy of the federal government and getting all parties on board was the most difficult aspect of creating the Space Force.

line
News & Events
Professor Lisa Fairfax gives testimony during Senate Judiciary Committee confirmation hearings for the nomination of Judge Kentanji Brown Jackson to the Supreme Court at the U.S. Capitol
Photo: MICHAEL REYNOLDS/EPA-EFE/Shutterstock
Up Arrow Professor Lisa Fairfax gives testimony during Senate Judiciary Committee confirmation hearings for the nomination of Judge Kentanji Brown Jackson to the Supreme Court at the U.S. Capitol.

Professor Lisa Fairfax Named to Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Board of Governors

The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) has appointed Lisa Fairfax, Presidential Professor and Co-Director of the Institute for Law and Economics, as one of 11 public governors on its Board of Governors.

“I care deeply about the health and safety of our financial markets and helping to ensure that we all have the ability to access the financial services we need to promote our financial wellbeing and guard against financial uncertainties,” Fairfax said.

“FINRA’s mission of investor protection and market integrity advances these ideals, and I am very excited and honored to join FINRA’s Board of Governors and play a role in support of such an important endeavor.”

News & Events
Michael Morse headshot
PHOTO: DAVE BARBAREE

Assistant Professor of Law Michael Morse C’13, an Expert on Voting Rights and Election Law, Joins the Faculty

Michael Morse C’13 joined the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School as an Assistant Professor of Law in Fall 2023. As he settled into his new role, Morse shared that he is “both thrilled and grateful to return home to Penn.” After graduating from the College, Morse earned a JD from Yale Law School and a PhD in political science from Harvard.

“For me,” he said, “joining the faculty at Penn Carey Law is a dream come true.”

Morse studies voting rights, election administration, and the criminal justice system. He also has a secondary appointment in the political science department. In general, his work combines empirical methods and novel administrative data with traditional legal scholarship.

line
News & Events

One Decade and Over 200 Alumni Later, Master in Law Program Lives Up to Its Ambitious Vision

In January 2014, the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School boldly entered a new dimension of legal education when it launched a groundbreaking program: the Master in Law (ML) degree, the Law School’s first degree designed for those working outside the legal profession and one of few new degrees introduced in over a century.

Ever a leader in driving innovation and excellence in cross-disciplinary legal education, Penn Carey Law was among the first top-ranked law schools to offer such a program.

The ML program’s early inspiration was rooted in a desire to better prepare those in the highly regulated field of medicine; before long, the ML’s potential to have a broader impact on a multitude of disciplines became clear.

Toward Tomorrow

Toward Tomorrow
Sophia Z. Lee Uses the Lens of History to Move Forward
By Larry Teitelbaum
photo: dave barbaree
New Penn Carey Law Dean Sophia Z. Lee is a born educator.
Winner of three teaching awards in the last five years, she has taught administrative, constitutional, and employment law. But she also teaches something you won’t find in the course selections and for which there is no syllabus: life lessons.

Drawing on her own lived experiences, Lee advises students to expect the unexpected. More than ever, she said, careers are malleable—where you start may be poles apart from where you end up. Her message is well-calibrated for this era of rapid change, both in society and in the legal profession.

“The career paths for our graduates are going to look really different than they did 20 or 30 years ago,” said Lee, Dean and Bernard G. Segal Professor of Law. “The legal profession is changing, so it is much less common to have a lockstep career ladder. I have tried to emphasize to my students that there are a lot of side paths off the main road.”

close up of Kia Del Solar
close up of Darius Iraj
close up of Olwethuthando Banele Ndlovu
close up of Veda Bhadharla
close up of Zachary Gluckow
close up of Jared Turner
Photos: Charles Shan Cerrone

The Thriving & Dynamic Student Life at Penn Carey Law

The Thriving & Dynamic Student Life at Penn Carey Law typography
By Eleanor Mallett
A

t Penn Carey Law, the culture of collegiality extends far beyond academics. Students commit themselves to three years of demanding and difficult classwork, arriving with a natural appetite for community-centered learning and nurturing deep social networks. With a vibrant, diverse population of over 800 JD students, roughly 100 LLMs, and over 100 MLs, the Law School is home to 7 student-run academic journals, 30 pro bono organizations, and 70 other student clubs. From the Jessup International Law Moot Court Team, which participates in the largest moot court competition in the world, to the Baking Club, which relieves students’ stress with fresh baked goods, everyone can find an outlet for their extracurricular interests here.

The ratio of students to organizations at Penn Carey Law is unusually high for a professional school with about 1,000 students and around 100 active clubs. In the last two decades, the Law School has maintained a steady student body size while the number of student groups has grown by at least 60.

Penn Carey Law takes an open approach to student organizational life. To start a new club, students submit a strong mission statement, list of club leaders, and 12 supporting signatures to establish a club and receive start-up funding.

Class Notes

Fine Print

Fine Print

1960s

1960s
Stephen Lipton L’66 was recognized at the Annual Florida Bar Convention’s Recognition Luncheon that honors 50-year Florida Bar members in good standing or members whose cumulative legal practice with the Florida Bar and one or more United States jurisdiction(s) totals 50 years, as of January 1, 2023. He is Managing Partner at McConnell Lipton in Fort Lauderdale and focuses his legal practice on real estate development, construction, and complex business claims. Lipton’s expertise involves construction projects, including project development, planning, design, implementation, and management; contract negotiations, drafting, interpretation, and administration; and risk management, dispute avoidance, and resolution. Lipton has a depth of experience in complex commercial litigation and trials, with more than 100 jury trials and countless other bench trials, evidentiary hearings, and other proceedings in state and federal courts.

Daniel Cohen L’68 received an honorary Doctor of Laws degree from Lafayette College, where he earned his undergraduate degree. Cohen is a Partner at Hof & Reid LLC, a Beth­lehem, Pennsylvania law firm specializing in personal injury law. His practice has concentrated in land use law, business organizations and corporate matters, transactions and wills, trusts, and estates. Cohen has served as a member of a hearing committee of the Disciplinary Board of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania and, in the nonprofit world, has served as President and board member of B’nai Abraham synagogue, Jewish Federation of the Lehigh Valley, Lehigh Valley Jewish Foundation, and ­ProJeCt of Easton Inc., as well as having served on the boards for the Hugh Moore Canal Commission, Premier Bank, now Fulton Bank, Friends of the State Theatre Inc., and City of Easton Police Practices Commission. At Lafayette, Cohen has assisted Gateway Career Center as a volunteer in various capacities including job fairs, internships, and the 1826 Law Society.

In Memoriam

—2023)

Judge Berger, a Beloved Figure at the Law School, was on the Launching Pad of Space Law

T

he Honorable Harold Berger EE’48, L’51, a space law pioneer, co-founder of a Philadelphia law firm, former judge, and staunch supporter of Penn, passed away on August 26 at the age of 98.

A beloved member of the Penn Carey Law community, then-Dean Ted Ruger presented him with the Law School’s inaugural Annual Lifetime Commitment Award in 2017. He called Judge Berger “the best ambassador Penn Law could ever have,” adding, “There’s only one word to describe Judge Berger: irrepressible. Just give him a minute… or two… or three, and he’ll extol the virtues of Penn and Penn Law School. No one loves Penn Law (and Engineering) more than Judge Berger.”

Judge Berger remained involved at Penn throughout his life. He made a gift to establish the Harold and Renee Berger Seminar Room in Tanenbaum Hall, and he served as Chair of the Friends of Biddle Law Library. He also established the library’s Harold Berger Air and Space Collection — which contains scholarship and treatises on aerospace law — in memory of his parents, Anna and Jonas Berger. He was the acting agent for his reunion class for many years. Additionally, he served on the executive board of the Center for Ethics and Rule of Law for many years and served on the board of Penn’s School of Engineering and Applied Science.

The Journal: University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School
Thanks for reading our Spring 2024 issue!